Editor's Pick
Editor’s Pick partnered with Stimulate to upgrade their retention marketing strategy, focusing on enhancing profitability and customer lifetime value. By driving subscription growth, implementing retention-first strategies, and reducing dependency on discounts, we helped transform their approach to retention—and their results.
Key Results:
98%
increase in repeat revenue per customer
29%
of sales attributed to subscriptions within 12 months of launch
104%
increase in 30-day repeat customers

Background
When Editor's Pick set out to boost profitability, they knew the key was improving customer loyalty and increasing lifetime value. That's where Stimulate came in. Our approach centered on growing subscriptions and keeping customers engaged—all while avoiding an overdependence on discounts and promotions.
.png)
Our Approach
To help Editor's Pick grow, we developed a retention-first strategy.
Protect LTV with Value-Led Content
We noticed that discounts over 10% often led customers to expect similar deals in the future, making it challenging to balance profits with loyalty. To tackle this, we scaled back on discounts and focused on highlighting everyday value, striking a better balance between sales and margins.
Create Targeted Campaigns
We segmented customers based on their favorite brands and unique skin concerns, allowing us to tailor campaigns to what mattered most to each group. This personalized approach delivered impressive results: click rates reached the 91st percentile, and conversion rates 3x better than the industry average.
Optimizing Replenishment and Subscriptions
We fine-tuned workflows to ensure perfect replenishment timing, simplify subscription management, and reduce churn. A key focus was encouraging second orders within 30 days, as customers who reordered in this window showed higher lifetime value. This approach boosted 30-day repeat customers by 104% and created a smoother, more convenient repurchase experience.
Key Takeaways
Avoid Discounting to Protect LTV
Prioritize acquiring customers through value-driven strategies to support sustainable growth.
Personalize Campaigns for Better Engagement
Tailor campaigns to match customers' interests and needs to lead to higher engagement and more substantial conversion rates.
Use Subscriptions and Replenishment to Strengthen Loyalty
Build consistent revenue and deepen customer relationships with timely reminders for replenishment and well-designed subscription programs.
Our Work

.png)

Featured cases
Unicorn Snot
Unicorn Snot, a Gen Z-focused glitter beauty brand, partnered with Stimulate to revamp their retention marketing strategy. By leveraging targeted promotions, optimizing automations, and aligning creative with their audience’s vibrant lifestyle, they achieved transformative results in customer loyalty and revenue growth.
43%
Increase in Lifetime Value (LTV)
91%
Increase in Repurchase Rates

Speks
Before starting with Speks, they were stuck at driving just 8.57% from email. Despite having key core flows like the welcome series, browse abandonment, and abandoned checkout and sending consistent campaigns 5x per month, their strategy lacked the conversion elements needed to scale up.
205%
YoY increase in managed revenue
253%
YoY increase in click rates

Begin Health
Begin Health partnered with Stimulate to transform their retention marketing strategy. By infusing their playful branding into every email and SMS campaign, we created a unique and engaging customer experience. Coupled with advanced post-purchase automation, this approach turned email into their fastest-growing channel and delivered a record-breaking year of growth.
$21
Increase in 12 month LTV
42%
Growth in repurchase rates

StackedSkincare
StackedSkincare partnered with Stimulate to elevate their retention marketing strategy and transform email into a powerful revenue channel. By migrating platforms, focusing on list growth, and creating high-converting content, we turned email into their fastest-growing marketing channel.
#1
Fastest growing channel
218%
YoY increase in list growth

Groom Here
Groom Here partnered with Stimulate to amplify their already successful email marketing strategy. By optimizing popups, enhancing deliverability, and introducing value-based content, we turned email into their fastest-growing revenue channel, increasing email revenue by 256% in just 12 months.
256%
YoY growth in email revenue
83%
Increase in popup CVRs

ezpz
ezpz partnered with Stimulate to transform their email marketing strategy by revamping automations, personalizing campaigns, and leveraging zero-party data to drive growth. The result? A major leap in revenue attributable to email and a substantial boost in engagement metrics, all within 90 days.
238%
Increase in click rates
476%
lift in popup conversion rates
.png)
Ready to scale?
Let’s make it happen!
Book your introductory call for a complimentary audit and custom proposal, and see exactly how we’ll help scale your brand.