.webp)
Sending a single non-compliant SMS could cost your business $500 per message.
Blast that on a list of 20,000 subscribers? That’s a potential $10 million in fines—before legal fees, platform shutdowns, or lost customer trust.
For ecommerce brands scaling email and SMS, privacy protection and compliance aren’t just checkboxes—they’re non-negotiable pillars of sustainable growth.
In this post, we’ll break down:
- What GDPR, CAN-SPAM, and TCPA actually mean
- How consent rules differ across email and SMS
- Innovative ways to stay compliant without killing conversions
- And what can happen if you get it wrong
Whether you're DIY-ing or working with an experienced email marketing agency, understanding the rules around consent and communication is critical for protecting your brand—and your budget.
Compliance 101: What These Acronyms Actually Mean
GDPR Compliance (General Data Protection Regulation)
The GDPR regulations apply to anyone collecting data from EU or UK citizens—even if your brand is based elsewhere.
The basics:
- You need explicit consent to collect, store, or use personal data.
- You must clearly state what you’re collecting and why.
- Users can access, correct, or delete their data at any time (“right to be forgotten”).
What trips brands up:
Just because someone enters their email at checkout doesn’t mean you can send them marketing. That requires separate consent.
CAN-SPAM (Controlling the Assault of Non-Solicited Pornography and Marketing Act)
The CAN-SPAM Act governs email marketing in the U.S., focusing on transparency, consent, and unsubscribe functionality.
The basics:
- Your messages must include a way to unsubscribe—and honor that request quickly.
- Subject lines must be truthful (no bait-and-switch).
- You’re required to include valid business contact info.
What trips brands up:
Automatically adding customers to a promotional list after a purchase—without giving them the option to opt in—is a common violation of CAN-SPAM.
TCPA (Telephone Consumer Protection Act)
The TCPA compliance rules apply specifically to SMS and text marketing within the U.S., and they come with some of the most severe penalties for violations.
The basics:
- You need prior express written consent before texting anyone promotional content.
- That consent must be explicit, unbundled, and well-documented.
- You must disclose how often you’ll text, what kind of messages they’ll receive, and that message/data rates may apply.
What trips brands up:
Using pre-checked boxes, bundling SMS and email consent, or not keeping proof of opt-in.
Consent: The Cornerstone of Compliance
Everything starts with consent—and each regulation defines it a little differently.
Valid Consent Must Be:
- Freely given (no tricks or pre-checked boxes)
- Informed (people know what they’re signing up for)
- Specific (no bundling SMS and email together)
- Recorded (you can prove when and how they opted in)
SMS vs. Email Opt-Ins:
Email consent is more flexible, especially under CAN-SPAM. But SMS consent is another story. If you’re using a pop-up or checkout form, you need a separate checkbox and disclosure for text marketing.
Double Opt-In: Worth It?
Double opt-in (where subscribers confirm their signup) isn’t required by law—but it can help with:
- Deliverability (especially in email)
- Proof of consent
- Reducing fake or mistyped signups
Avoid These Common Mistakes:
- Pre-filled checkboxes (illegal under GDPR and TCPA)
- Fine print that hides how you’ll use data
- Combining email + SMS opt-in into one catch-all statement
- Failing to explain what type of messages people will receive
How to Stay Compliant Without Killing Conversions
Compliance doesn’t mean sacrificing growth. You have to be smart about it.
Build Smart, Compliant Opt-In Forms:
- Use clear CTAs like “Sign up for texts and get 15% off.”
- Separate SMS from email (two checkboxes are fine!)
- Include disclosure language: message frequency, terms, and privacy link
- Avoid vague language—transparency builds trust
Use Incentives (Ethically):
Discounts, gated content, early access, and giveaways are great motivators for signups—just ensure opt-in is still voluntary and transparent.
Use the Right Tools:
Platforms like Klaviyo, Attentive, and Postscript give ecommerce brands the power to manage consent, store opt-in records, and keep SMS services compliant—without sacrificing automation or performance.
Real CTA Examples That Work:
- “Sign up for emails & get early access to our Black Friday sale.”
- “Join our text club for 10% off—2 texts max per week. Msg & data rates may apply.”
- “Want the secret drop? Text JOIN to 12345.”
Clean. Clear. Compliant.
What Happens If You Don’t Comply
It’s not just theory—brands have gotten hit hard for ignoring the rules.
Real Consequences:
- $500–$1,500 per SMS violation under TCPA
- Six-figure fines from GDPR authorities for sloppy consent
- Blacklistings that tank deliverability
- Email/SMS platforms suspending your account
- Class action lawsuits from people who never opted in
Even if you win in court, the legal fees, PR mess, and lost trust are rarely worth the shortcut.
Final Thoughts: Stay Smart. Stay Compliant. Stay in Business.
Compliance isn't optional if your brand is scaling retention through email and SMS—it’s part of sustainable growth.
The good news? Getting it right doesn’t have to kill conversions. In fact, smart compliance builds trust, increases engagement, and keeps you out of legal hot water.
If you're investing in retention marketing and want to scale email and SMS without entering legal gray areas, Stimulate is here to help.
We’re an email marketing agency that also specializes in SMS services. We know how to build retention channels that are high-converting and 100% compliant.
👉 Book your free retention compliance audit today.
